Who's actually
good

Every quarterback and every coach, graded with the opponent, the scheme, and the supporting cast taken out — so the number is the player, not the circumstances. Updated weekly. By Throw in the Towel.

Free to read · Public · Decomposable · 2026 season, live

The numbers people argue about

The TTT Index is a set of football ratings built to be argued with. Every number breaks into the factors that made it, each one ranked — so you can sort it, challenge it, and see exactly why a quarterback or a coach lands where he does. The question underneath all of it isn't what happened on Sunday. It's who's actually good.

QBIRThe Quarterback Independent Rating

Every QB graded as if dropped into a neutral situation, opponent, scheme and supporting cast partialled out by a play-level model, then fused with charting grades, production and track record into one 0–100 number. Seven visible factors, a value-over-average (PTS/G), and a turnover-luck column.

93.5Leader · Purdy
29QBs rated
7factors
See the board →

Coach IndexNFL scheme identities

Every play-caller and coordinator as a data skeleton, PROE, play-action, personnel groupings, blitz and coverage rates, pass & run efficiency, credited to the coach who actually ran it (the Vikings' pressure to Flores, not O'Connell). Current staffs, free agents, and the whole career, ranked.

120+coaches
2sides of the ball
2023–26charted
See the board →

WR / RB IndexReceiver & back ratings

The same situation-independent treatment for the skill positions, separation, YAC, route value and usage, stripped of scheme and quarterback. Coming

CollegeThe draft pipeline

QB and coach ratings for the college game, from the CFBD data, the scouting layer that feeds the pros. Coming

Transparent, situation-stripped, honest

Anyone can tell you what a player or team did. We estimate how good they actually are, and show every step.

01Situation-independent

A play-level ridge model partials out the opponent, the scheme and the supporting cast. QBIR asks what the quarterback himself is worth, regardless of where he plays. The Coach Index credits each scheme to the coach who ran it.

02Fully decomposable

No black box. Every grade breaks into its factors, every factor carries its league rank, and you can sort by any of them. A rating you can't take apart is a rating you can't argue with — so we show the whole thing.

03Honest about limits

Small samples carry a reliability flag. Data gaps are stated, not faked. When a number leans on a prior or is early-season, the page says so. The limits are part of the story.

04Built on real data

The raw data is nflverse play-by-play and charting plus PFF grades. The model, the attribution, and the number are ours.

Free to read. More for the committed.

The boards are free, every week — that's the point. One membership unlocks the rest: the full depth, the writing, and the Fantasy and Draft apps. One account, the whole of Throw in the Towel.

Free
$0
The ratings, open to everyone.
  • Live QBIR + Coach Index boards
  • Every factor & per-stat rank
  • Player & coach cards
  • 1 fantasy league + the draft board
Start reading
Membership
$10/mo
Everything TTT. The full house.
  • Full Index depth: history, projections, exports
  • Fantasy Pro: unlimited leagues, AI, trade, odds
  • Draft Intelligence, full access
  • Premium Substack data-stories
Coming soon

Founding members lock the launch price for life.  ·  Building something? An API for our ratings is coming for sites, tools & bettors.

Part of Throw in the Towel

Sports stories told through data. The Index is the engine; the writing and the apps are the rest of the house.